Robbie Amell stars on The CW’s new show The Tomorrow People, joining Arrow star and cousin Stephen Amell on the Wednesday night lineup, which fans have dubbed #AmellWednesdays.

And with the arrival of Stephen and wife Cassandra Jean‘s little baby girl Mavi Alexandra Jean Amell on October 15, does Robbie see himself taking on babysitting duties any time soon?

Robbie gushes to On Air with Ryan Seacrest that he’s met the little bundle of joy and admits she’s the cutest ever … but he’s not too confident when it comes to his sitting skills.

“I have a phobia of holding babies,” the 25-year-old jokes. ”I’m just terrified of dropping them, so I told him if I ever babysit we’re setting up a bed full of pillows and I’m not leaving that one area while they’re gone.”

He might be unsure, but we think Robbie would look quite cute holding a baby!

Source: Ryan Seacrest